The rape and murder of 9-year-old Marise Ann Chiverella on March 8th 1964 in Hazleton, Pennsylvania was finally solved in 2022, when her killer was identified as James Paul Forte using semen stains from the jacket of the young girl. Forte, 22 years of age at the time of the murder, was a bartender in the area, who abducted the young girl as she made her way to school with canned goods for her teacher, who subsequently dumped her lifeless body in a coal-mining pit. This crime, solved by genetic genealogy, predated the case of Nancy Bennallack, but by no means is the oldest case solved using this crime-fighting DNA tool as the Patricia Kalitzke and Duane Bogle double murder case in 1956 showed.

The murder of 28-year-old court reporter Nancy Bennallack on October 25/26th 1970 was recently solved using genetic genealogy, identifying Richard John Davis who lived in the same apartment complex, as her killer. Stabbed more than 30 times and nearly decapitated, it is a reasonable assumption that Davis realized Nancy Bennallack's fiance had left her apartment that night at 11:30pm and noticed that she had left her second story balcony window open, which he accessed by scaling from beneath. Genetic genealogy was only possible in this case because investigators realized that a trail of blood from Nancy Bennallack's apartment to the parking lot, where it ended, had a strong possibility of being secreted by her murderer. A similar trail of blood was mentioned by investigators in the case of Cheri Jo Bates, that bridged the body and Terracina Drive in Riverside, and was noticed by responding officers on October 31st 1966. A blood trail distance of approximately 100 feet, unlikely to have been deposited by a dripping knife measuring 3 1/2 inches long and half an inch wide. The blood typing of Cheri Jo Bates detailed at autopsy of AB RhD positive is rare, accounting for only 3.4% of the American population. If this blood trail had been sampled and tested (as it should have been), then not only would it have been easy to determine whether the blood was shed by the killer or Cheri Jo Bates, but we would have ample material (if stored correctly) to apply genetic genealogy to this case as well.   

Richard John Davis and Nancy Bennallack may have crossed paths many times, as they were both resident at the Tahitian apartment complex at 1830 Bell Street in Sacramento. When Richard John Davis became fixated on Nancy Bennallack is unknown, but they would have shared a communal pool had either of them chosen to use it. Why Davis chose to attack Nancy is also unknown, but it doesn't require great speculation that a sexual motive was the likely driver that night. His choice of placing masking tape over his fingertips clearly indicated this was a premeditated attack requiring some forethought. The idea that Davis may have set his sights on Miss Bennallack possibly days or weeks in advance of the crime, with some preparation, along with the observable blood trail ending in the parking lot of the Tahitian apartment complex, is not incongruent to the attack on Judith Hakari approximately 7 1/2 months earlier. If Davis set his sights on Bennallack, he could have set his sights on Hakari, who lived at the 1740 Markston Road apartments. The communal pool at the Markston apartments sits just 760 feet from the communal pool at the Tahitian apartments.

On March 7th 1970, Judith Hakari (23) left her job at the Sutter Memorial Hospital at 11;30pm, likely arriving in her Mercury Cougar at the parking lot of the Markston apartments at 11:45pm, from where she was immediately abducted. This may be the same time that Richard John Davis began his attack on Nancy Bennallack, shortly after her fiance left the second floor apartment on October 25th 1970. The walk for Judith Hakari from her vehicle to the door of her Markston Road apartment was a matter of seconds, so the likelihood of a random killer just happening upon the young 23-year-old in this small window of time is unlikely. This is further negated because her Mercury Cougar interior was scattered with torn strips of Cannon-brand towel, strongly suggestive of an abduction with premeditation and a second vehicle.

​The idea that a pretty 23-year-old nurse traveling to and from Sutter Memorial Hospital at set times, could become the target of a pre-planned abduction by a perpetrator or perpetrators, who ruminated in the days or weeks before the abduction, is not without merit. One individual (or multiple) fixating on Judith Hakari, just like Richard John Davis may have in the case of Nancy Bennallack is a reasonable hypothesis. His original intention could have been the abduction (and possibly torture) of Nancy Bennallack, before something changed the dynamics of that crime (possibly his injury). The fact that his blood trail ceased in the parking lot and not his front door, could suggest a vehicle was waiting in the parking lot of the Tahitian apartment compex, with or without accomplices. It is perfectly conceivable that the actions of Nancy Bennallack prevented her from being abducted to a second location, that ultimately befell Judith Hakari several months earlier. 

PART ONE   

On Saturday, March 7th 1970 at approximately 11:30pm, registered nurse Judith Ann Hakari left the Sutter Memorial Hospital at the end of her shift for the short 10 to 15 minute drive back to her apartment at 1740 Markston Road in Sacramento. The young 23-year-old woman had arranged to meet up with her fiance, Raymond Willis (24) of 5425 San Francisco Boulevard, who was anticipating her arrival at around 11:45pm. According to Raymond Willis, he had waited for Judith until 1:45am but became concerned when she didn't show up, venturing out into the parking lot of the Markston apartments to see if her vehicle was present. Upon seeing her car in its usual parking spot he understandably became concerned and rang the sheriff's office to report her missing. Her Mercury Cougar showed signs of foul play, with the passenger door open, her ignition keys on the floorboard, with buttons and ripped strips of Cannon-brand towel scattered inside the vehicle. First impressions seemed to indicate Judith Hakari, wearing her nurses uniform and a blue coat with white polka dots, had been forcibly removed from her Mercury Cougar as she arrived at the parking lot by one or more assailants. An immediate search of local fields turned up nothing. 

For her father, Wilho Hakari of 4532 Sycamore Drive, Carmichael, the next few days were a tortuous affair, remarking that "This is hellish, just sitting here and not knowing and not being able to do something. She knows wherever she may be and no matter what happens, she is loved". The mother of Judith stated "Please, I beg of you, whomever has taken my child, in some anonymous way contact authorities so we can find her. We just want to bring her home to take care of her".

​Investigators immediately issued a one thousand dollar reward to anybody with information on her whereabouts, but as the days turned into weeks, hopes of finding the 5'2", 118 lbs, brunette alive started to fade away. These hopes were completely dashed when on April 25th 1970, just seven weeks after her abduction, a grisly discovery was made by Leonard Theis (26) and his girlfriend Susan Reed (19) while visiting old mine shafts alongside the extremely rural Ponderosa Way in Weimar, who noticed a knee protruding from the earth and immediately reported their finding to police. Leonard Theis stated "We had spent the day hiking around the American River canyon country, panning gold and looking for places to fish. We had gone back to my car on a dirt road off Ponderosa Way in Weimar, and were going to leave when I remembered, from once before when I was in the area, a small mine and an old cabin. I told Susan 'Let go back and look at the gold mine'. We saw a knee protruding from the dirt between the cabin and the mine, a shaft which goes about five feet into a slope". Leonard Theis described the grave as very crude, as though somebody had just thrown dirt over the body and tamped it down a little. He added "There are all kinds of places near where a grave could have been hidden better than that". Sheriff-Coroner William A. Scott described the grave as approximately four feet long by two feet wide and 24 inches deep. William Scott stated that "she was the victim of one of the most godawful assaults I've ever investigated". 

After an examination of the body, pathologist Dr. Donald Jones unearthed the gruesome findings of a cruel death. Judith Hakari had been so savagely beaten, her nose had been reduced to a pulp, her jaw had been broken in several places, some teeth had been knocked out, and she had been strangled by her own stocking causing a fractured hyoid bone. She had also been sexually attacked (possibly raped), with the perpetrator/s placing her underwear in the grave beneath her body, which was still dressed in her nurse's uniform, partially wrapped in a canvas bag (manufactured in Sacramento for the San Juan Unified School District). Although she was still wearing a diamond ring, one of Judith Hakari's shoes was missing, along with her nurse's watch and purse. Despite an extensive examination of the gravesite alongside Ponderosa Way, Lieutenant Arthur Ables, co-ordinating the investigation, and Sheriff's Inspectors William Ravenscroft and Edward Reynolds, failed to uncover any further clues to crack the case.

Eleven days after Judith Hakari's body was found, on May 6th 1970, it was revealed that Placer and Sacramento County officers were searching for three men with respect to the murder, after the landowner of the site where Judith Hakari was buried came forward to reveal his sighting of three men digging at that location. He told police that three well-dressed men had parked their sedan in that area with the trunk open. When he approached them and asked what they were doing, they responded by claiming they were digging for antique glass bottles, told him not to touch the car and closed the trunk lid as he got closer. He described one of the young men in his late twenties, 6'0" tall, slender to medium build, with dark brown hair, brown eyes and an olive complexion. The other two suspects were also described as aged in their late 20s, with all three wearing shirts and slacks. The landowner relayed to police he saw the three men digging the grave six days after Judith Hakari's abduction (March 13th 1970). Investigators surmised that Judith Hakari may have suffered days of abuse and torture before finally being killed and buried 677 feet from Ponderosa Way, 48 miles from the Markston apartments where she was abducted from. Investigators wisely concluded that one or more of the men must have been familiar with area Judith Hakari was buried.

The year 1970 ended with the hunt still ongoing in the murders of 23-year-old Judith Hakari (March 7th to March 13th), 28-year-old Nancy Bennallack (October 25th or 26th) and 22-year-old Carol Beth Hilburn (November 14th), described in a newspaper article entitled Year Ends, But Hunt For Killers Of Three Capital Women Goes On. The newspaper made comparisons between the brutal deaths of the three women, with Carol Beth Hilburn and Judith Hakari receiving a brutal beating to their face, with Nancy Bennallack suffering at least 30 stab wounds and near decapitation. Wilho Hakari described the murderer of his daughter as "an animal, not a human", with detectives contemplating whether one or more persons were involved in each murder. The newspaper noted the close proximity of the Markston apartments parking lot (where Judith Hakari was abducted) to the residence of Nancy Bennallack, who lived at the Tahitian apartments on 1830 Bell Street. The two locations are about 850 feet apart. The Hakari and Bennallack murders were both described as extremely brutal, in which both of their faces were attacked, both were engaged to be married, both were attacked at weekends and both women were employed in professional fields. Although Lieutenant Jerry Saulter was quick to caution in drawing the conclusion these two murders were connected  Below is an older photograph of Richard John Davis, recently identified as the murderer of Nancy Bennallack. A younger photograph would be advantageous in making a comparison to the sketches created in the Bennallack and Hakari slayings. Richard John Davis must be considered a potential suspect in the murder of Judith Hakari. 

Nancy Bennallack (28) was murdered either late on October 25th 1970, or the early morning hours of the 26th. Her fiance, Farris Salamy, had left Nancy Bennallack's apartment at 11:30pm, so if Richard John Davis (who lived in the same apartment complex) had noticed she was now alone, he may have struck shortly after this time, either acting alone or in accompaniment with others. It is believed he made access to her apartment by climbing up to the second story balcony and entering through the sliding doors, which Nancy Bennallack had unfortunately left open for her cat to come and go. Investigators noted a blood trail from her apartment to the parking lot, where it ended - which led them to believe that the suspect may have made his getaway by vehicle.

​A trail of the assailant's blood (believed to be from his hand or arm) was sampled and stored, and was later instrumental in identifying Richard John Davis through genetic genealogy in 2022. Richard John Davis (born in 1943) was 27 years of age at the time of the murder (and according to his roommate lived at the Tahitian apartments until 1974 or 1975). In addition to the comparisons noted above, both the murder of Nancy Bennallack and abduction of Judith Hakari may have occurred just before midnight at the weekend, with the trail going cold in each case in the parking lot of two apartments, separated by 850 feet in distance. One has to ask the question, why did the blood trail end in the parking lot of the Tahitian apartments and not the home of Richard John Davis? There could of course be many reasons - but maybe it was deliberately engineered to give the impression of a getaway vehicle, and a murderer not resident in the Tahitian apartments or close vicinity? Or was a vehicle parked here with the original intention of abducting Nancy Bennallack from her apartment, similar to the abduction of Judith Hakari? If Davis had an accomplice (such as a lying roommate, or friend), it may have been wise to use a vehicle and leave the area to dispose of the weapon and misdirect police away from the apartment complex.

​It will be interesting to discover more details on the characteristics and life of Richard John Davis in the coming months, and see if he can pass as a man of 6'0" tall, slender to medium build, with dark brown/black hair, brown eyes and an olive complexion, driving a sedan. We already know he was the correct age range when the landowner spotted the three individuals on March 13th 1970. Additonally, did he, his roommate, or any of his friends have any connection to the San Juan Unified School District canvas bag found in the gravesite of Judith Hakari? Time will tell. 

PART TWO

Solve Crimes with Rick & Gavin is a new Youtube channel, website, true crime podcast series and forum where you can get involved and help to find a resolution to the many unsolved murders and disappearances that have haunted so many people for far too long. In the words of Rick & Gavin "help us solve the mystery and provide the victim, the victim's family, community and law enforcement with justice and peace of mind".

They invite you to join their burgeoning venture by joining the forum, providing new information or tips, suggesting possible new cold cases for them to investigate and even the option of confessing to a crime (and hopefully remove all the murderers and criminals that visit my site). To date they have currently produced six extremely well-researched Youtube videos on the murder of Judith Hakari (currently 4), the disappearance of Denise Anderson and an additional video entitled "Killer Wine" (I will leave you to work that one out). They welcome everybody with a keen interest in solving cold cases to cooperatively make this venture an ongoing success, which judging by the first few videos I have no doubt it will be. To view each video shown below, click the images. 

Rick Tracewell and Gavin Fish present an introductory first episode regarding the abduction and murder of Judith Ann Hakari (23) on March 7th 1970 outside the Markston Apartments in Sacramento. This video presentation will include a mixture of crime scene imagery, newspaper cuttings, and a back and forth discussion between Rick and Gavin. They will also touch on the Nancy Bennallack, Carol Beth Hilburn and Donna Lass crimes, to be expanded upon in further episodes.   

The second episode explores in much more detail the abduction of Judith Hakari, along with the devastating impact this crime had on the family and community. The episode concentrates mainly on the crime scene outside of the Markston Apartments and the condition her vehicle was found by her boyfriend, Raymond Willis (24), at approximately 1:45 am. There would be no happy ending seven weeks later when the body of Judith Hakari was unearthed in Placer County. As Gavin stated "The Placer County Sheriff's Offce were very swift to go and notify the Hakari's - and that is when the first chapter of their nightmare ended".

The third episode takes you on a journey between the two crime scenes and apartments of Judith Hakari and Nancy Bennallack. This young woman was brutally stabbed in the Tahitian Apartment complex on October 25th/26th 1970, located just 830 feet from the Markston Apartments. No solid link has ever been forged between the two murders, but their close proximity within eight months of each other has led to much speculation regarding a single perpetrator. Offender DNA has been secured in the case of Nancy Bennallack.

The fourth episode explores the discovery of Judith Hakari's shallow grave alongside Ponderosa Way in Weimar and its implications regarding the possible perpetrator or perpetrators of the savage and brutal murder of the young nurse. Rick & Gavin detail the items found at the crime scene and an eyewitness to three men acting suspiciously in the area prior to the discovery of her body. Judith Hakari went missing on March 7th 1970, with her body discovered by two hikers on April 25th 1970. Episode five.

The sixth episode covers the rarely covered case of Denise Kathleen Anderson (22), who was last seen in her 925 16th Street apartment in Sacramento on April 13th 1971. Information on this crime is so lacking and threadbare, they have done an excellent job in airing this crime for 29 minutes. I say crime, because the body of Denise Anderson has never been found, despite everything pointing to an abduction at, or in close proximity to her residence. If you knew Denise Anderson, or have any information on her life and disappearance, please contact Rick & Gavin via the website link posted above.   

Judith Hakari (23) was abducted from the parking lot of the Markston Apartments on March 7th 1970 at approximately 11:30 pm, after returning home from her nurses shift at the Sutter Memorial Hospital in Sacramento. Her partially buried body was discovered by two hikers on April 25th 1970 just 677 feet off Ponderosa Way, near Weimar. The location of her burial site was 43 miles from the site of her abduction and 3.1 miles from Interstate 80 at Weimar.

Her Mercury Cougar (discovered by her boyfriend) showed signs of foul play, with the passenger door open, her ignition keys on the floorboard, buttons scattered about and ripped strips of Cannon-brand towel, indicating that these may have been used to restrain the young woman. The same style toweling was discovered in the burial site of Judith Hakari seven weeks later and therefore provided a common link between both locations. Her body was found inside a canvas laundry bag, laying over a grey sweatshirt. She had been savagely beaten in the face, strangled and raped, with her bra torn in two and her underwear found beneath her.

Detectives stated that on March 13th 1970 (six days after her disappearance) the owner of the land where Judith Hakari was eventually discovered, noticed three sharply-dressed men in their late 20s at the site with the trunk of their vehicle open and digging into the ground. Their lame excuse of digging for bottles, while suspiciously closing the trunk of their vehicle seemed sinister. There is very good reason to believe these three men were involved in the murder and disposal of Judith Hakari. At the very least, one murderer and two accomplices after the fact. With little to go on after 50 years, an examination of the abduction and burial site can reveal so much about this crime.        

The presence of ripped toweling in Judith Hakari's vehicle indicated malice aforethought. The killer or killers had possibly pre-planned this abduction ahead of time with the primary goal of feeding their sexual peversion at the cost of a young and promising life. Judith Hakari had to travel a matter of seconds from her Mercury Cougar to the front door of her residence. We have to weigh up the odds of a random and opportunistic abduction in this slender window of time, to the possibility that somebody knew her routine and lay in wait. An attractive 23-year-old young woman, dressed in a nurses uniform, following a regular pattern to and from Sutter Memorial Hospital each day, always has the potential to draw in the sickest of predators. Judith Hakari arriving back to her apartment complex at a similar time each night may very well have been noticed by such an individual, who came pre-prepared with materials of restraint. This opens up the possibility that the perpetrator or perpetrators lived in the same Markston Apartments as Judith Hakari, or in close proximity to it. Or she was trailed from Sutter Memorial Hospital.  

Nancy Bennallack (28), a court reporter, was found brutally stabbed numerous times at the Tahitian Apartments on October 25th 1970. The Tahitian Apartments were just 830 feet from the Markston Apartments, where Judith Hakari was abducted just seven months earlier. Two young women attacked in and around their apartments opens up the possibility of a single perpetrator who specifically targeted both of these women. Update: Recent discoveries through genetic genealogy in 2022 has identified Richard John Davis as the murderer of Nancy Bennallack, who lived in the same apartment complex as the victim. Sadly, Richard Davis will elude justice because he died of an alcohol related illness in 1997.

We can now switch to the burial location of Judith Hakari, highly suggestive of somebody who had frequented this location before. The perpetrator or perpetrators of this murder had clearly used the canvas bag to transport the lifeless body of Judith Hakari - which if had been done by the three well-dressed men  - must have been done six days after her abduction. Whether she was killed a short time after her abduction and stored, or held captive for several days, will likely never be known unless a resolution is found in the next few years. The notion of a killer distancing the body from his home location is not unusual, so as to shift the focus of the investigation to another area. But whoever abducted Judith Hakari made no attempt to disguise the fact she was the victim of foul play, leaving her vehicle in disarray outside of her apartment complex.

The killer or killers chose the extremely remote, hilly and winding road of Ponderosa Way. They could have pulled up their vehicle on the roadside edge and tossed the body of Judith Hakari in a matter of seconds down any steep ravine into dense woodland, where she may have gone undetected for months, years, or forever. They could have thrown her body into the North Fork American River, thereby destroying any remaining evidence on the body. Instead, they inexplicably chose to pull onto a dirt road off Ponderosa Way into an area containing wooden buildings, near an old deserted mine entrance. This appears to suggest that this location was known to them - and in relative seclusion away from the main roadway - it would allow them the time to dig a grave. So, what advantage was the killer or killers attempting to gain by delaying or preventing the discovery of the body? They certainly made no effort to disguise the abduction. Was it simply a case of no body, no murder?

The likelihood is that the three young men were responsible for the burial of Judith Hakari, with at least one directly involved in her savage murder. The crime was undoubtedly pre-planned by somebody who had observed her routine and took full advantage of a dark, secluded parking lot at near midnight. Although not conclusive, it appears as though her abductor was either familiar with the young woman from Sutter Memorial Hospital or her comings and goings from the Markston Apartments. The canvas bag, manufactured in Sacramento for the San Juan Unified School District and the ripped toweling could provide a tenuous link to the people responsible.

There is little to suggest the abduction and murder of Judith Hakari has anything to do with the Zodiac Killer, despite the fact he may have latched onto her murder through the San Francisco Chronicle article on September 26th 1970, featuring the disappearance of Donna Lass on September 6th 1970. By mailing the Pines card on March 22nd 1971, he was effectively insinuating he was in the Lake Tahoe/Placer County area in the near timeframe. The murder and rape of Judith Hakari showed none of the features of the Zodiac killings, other than a propensity to rob young victims of their lives with no remorse.

There is a well-researched and informative documentary series on Youtube called Solve Crimes with Rick & Gavin, taking a deep dive into the story of Judith Hakari. If you want to extend your knowledge on the murder of Judith Hakari and hopefully forge a resolution to this 50-year-old case, please click the link above. Or visit their website here.