For five years, since the 340 cipher was cracked by David Oranchak, Sam Blake and Jarl Van Eycke, people have been under the misconception that the Zodiac Killer made many mistakes when encoding his 340 character message, but the reality is almost certainly different, with only eight mistakes yet to be fully explained in his cipher. I have found only four mistakes in the first 9 rows, and the same number in the second 9 rows, giving us eight mistakes in 340 operations during the encoding process, which is a success rate of 97.65%. The Zodiac Killer upped the level of difficulty from the 408 cipher to the 340 cipher, probably in response to the speed his first offering was cracked. However, no one likely expected the Zodiac Killer to ramp up the difficulty level from the first 9 rows to the second 9 rows in this one cipher. He clearly overestimated its complexity, because the message he masked behind a wall of ciphertext was of a contemporary nature, intended to be read in 1969 or 1970, not half a century later. The notion purveyed of a killer who bumbled his way through the 340 cipher, losing concentration numerous times during the encipherment process, can now be utterly dispelled. This cipher was as devious as it comes.
The Zodiac Killer made the 340 cipher more difficult by using a combination of substitution and transposition to disguise his message, but he added a third layer in the second 9 rows of the cipher by adding 14 deliberate spelling mistakes in an organized pattern 9 spaces apart (running diagonally across the cipher). The Zodiac Killer not only hid his message by using a 9 shift (and negative 8 shift) technique shown here, but he would further complicate matters for codebreakers by baking in these spelling mistakes using the same 9 shift technique. If you thought that was the last hurdle codebreakers had to overcome you would be mistaken, because a fourth layer was added, also 9 spaces apart. The Zodiac Killer placed the phrase "LIFE IS" into his message, inserted deliberately into certain positions so that it would appear at the end of the 10th row of the original 340 cipher when the key was applied. Below are the 14 deliberate spelling errors he placed into his message, running diagonally across the grid (black rectangles). The four green circles, I believe, are the accidental errors made by the Zodiac Killer. These concepts were fully explained in the previous article No Cipher Mistakes by Zodiac.
The Zodiac Killer made the 340 cipher more difficult by using a combination of substitution and transposition to disguise his message, but he added a third layer in the second 9 rows of the cipher by adding 14 deliberate spelling mistakes in an organized pattern 9 spaces apart (running diagonally across the cipher). The Zodiac Killer not only hid his message by using a 9 shift (and negative 8 shift) technique shown here, but he would further complicate matters for codebreakers by baking in these spelling mistakes using the same 9 shift technique. If you thought that was the last hurdle codebreakers had to overcome you would be mistaken, because a fourth layer was added, also 9 spaces apart. The Zodiac Killer placed the phrase "LIFE IS" into his message, inserted deliberately into certain positions so that it would appear at the end of the 10th row of the original 340 cipher when the key was applied. Below are the 14 deliberate spelling errors he placed into his message, running diagonally across the grid (black rectangles). The four green circles, I believe, are the accidental errors made by the Zodiac Killer. These concepts were fully explained in the previous article No Cipher Mistakes by Zodiac.
THE BLUE RECTANGLES SPELL "LIFE IS"
THE BLUE RECTANGLES SPELLING "LIFE IS" ARE ADDED LETTERS RATHER THAN SPELLING MISTAKES
Below is the Zodiac Killer's encoded message with the spelling errors rectified (in brown). There is absolutely no way the Zodiac Killer accidentally made these 14 mistakes in such an organized pattern. If you add the "LIFE IS" phrase into the mix (blue rectangles), it gives us 20 deliberate "errors" by the Zodiac Killer, all organized diagonally 9 spaces apart.
This leads us to the Zodiac Killer's next "13-Symbol" cipher mailed on April 20th 1970, in which the Zodiac Killer introduced the code with the phrase "This is the Zodiac speaking. By the way have you cracked the last cipher I sent you? My name is....". If we had cracked the last cipher he sent us, we would have known that the message was encoded behind a simple combination of 9 and 8 shift techniques, which if applied to the 13-Symbol cipher encodes the message of "ME ⊕" ("ME" followed by the Zodiac crosshairs). Simply traveling 8 positions to the right of each circled 8 and cycling through the 13-Symbol cipher, gives us the "identity" of "ME ⊕". A signature twice highlighted in the Halloween card on October 27th 1970, and given to us directly by the Zodiac Killer in the Exorcist letter on January 29th 1974. All these three communications teased us with the promise of a name, and all can easily be shown to give us the signature of "Me" in their design. The personal pronoun of "ME" was synonymous with the pseudonym "Zodiac" and his "crosshairs", hence the use of "Me-37" in his Exorcist letter rather than "⊕-37", a format he usually chose. Was the Zodiac Killer playing one big joke on us all? See here.
THE Z13 CODE MAILED ON APRIL 20TH 1970, SHOWN WITH SHIFT OF 8
The Zodiac Killer's 340 cipher was broken up into 3 parts of 9, 9 and 2 rows. This was the initial key to solving the 340 cipher. If we apply the same methodology across the Z13 and cycle through the code (9th, 18th and 20th positions), we get 888, the key to solving the Zodiac Killer's 13-Symbol cipher. See here.
Z13 CIPHER WITH 9, 9, 2 CONFIGURATION (SAME AS THE 340 CIPHER)
THE HALLOWEEN CARD WITH "MAGAZINE ENTERPRISES" AND TIM HOLT INSERT. CLICK THE IMAGE ABOVE FOR BY GUN, BY KNIFE, BY FIRE AND BY ROPE COMIC BOOK ISSUE NUMBER 30.
SIGNATURE ON THE EXORCIST LETTER
The first 18 rows of the 340 cipher reads I HOPE YOU ARE HAVING LOTS OF FUN IN TRYING TO CATCH ME - THAT WASN’T ME ON THE TV SHOW - WHICH BRINGS UP A POINT ABOUT ME - I AM NOT AFRAID OF THE GAS CHAMBER BECAUSE IT WILL SEND ME TO PARADICE ALL THE SOONER BECAUSE I NOW HAVE ENOUGH SLAVES TO WORK FOR ME WHERE EVERYONE ELSE HAS NOTHING WHEN THEY REACH PARADICE - SO THEY ARE AFRAID OF DEATH - I AM NOT AFRAID BECAUSE I KNOW THAT MY NEW LIFE IS. It is clear that the first 9 rows of the cipher (in black) carried the important part of Zodiac's message, where he confirms that it wasn't him on the TV show, and he was not afraid of the gas chamber. However, the second part of his message (in blue) is pretty irrelevant drivel about "paradice" and "slaves", copying much of what was present in the 408 cipher. This may be the reason the Zodiac Killer created the first 9 rows of the cipher with less complexity and without the designed spelling mistakes present in the second 9 rows. He probably cared less about the second part of his message being deciphered. The amount of cleverness baked into the 340 cipher shows that the Zodiac Killer knew perfectly well that the design of the Z13 and Z32 codes were incompatible with normal cryptographic techniques using all the ciphertext, which is why anybody adopting this approach is quite frankly wasting their time. These two codes require a much more nuanced approach, along with an in depth knowledge of the Zodiac case spanning several years..
RSS Feed
